Online Reviews

Online reviews are important to many businesses including our own. If you’re a current customer and would take a moment to leave us a review of your own, we would really appreciate it! Or, If you’re just curious to see what our customers have to say about us, take a moment to read a few of the reviews found on these sites.

Give Us an Online Review!

Give Our Madison Office a Review

Give Our Sun Prairie Office a Review

Recent Reviews

Homewood Insurance Agency

4.8

Based on 95 reviews

Dana S.

20:36 07 Apr 21

Great to work with - super quick responses always!

Janice V.

01:08 05 Apr 21

Monty has been our agent for quite some years now and we're so glad to have him!Our previous agent was curt and dismissive every time we had a question about our policy or premiums. Monty has been the complete opposite, has been nothing but responsive and super friendly to interact with.We had gotten into an accident on Easter Sunday, I emailed Monty the details thinking he'd get back to me the following day, Monday. Instead, he replied back the same day with options and solutions to handle the claim.I'd recommend Monty, if you're looking for a personable agent who will go above and beyond to meet your insurance needs.

Carol F

14:33 14 Mar 21

Excellent customer service and response time!

Cindy P.

01:00 14 Mar 21

Always helpful and responsive when I’ve needed them. Monty is great to work with I would recommend the agency to anyone looking for a good deal

Prestige I.

17:21 12 Mar 21

I am very difficult to work with, I don't know how Monty and his Team put up with me. Thanks for your patience.

Renee S.

16:15 12 Mar 21

Always quick to answer questions

MAKEUP BY AMBER K.

22:26 08 Feb 21

Excellent Customer Service!!!

Greg D.

02:32 04 Jan 21

Great agent and staff!

Mark B.

21:39 22 Dec 20

Monty is great to work with. Has the best rates around for Auto and Home with great coverage. Was able to save me alot of money over the years. Been with him for over 10 years.

Stacey T.

20:24 20 Dec 20

Monty has been great to work with. He continues to review our coverage to ensure we are getting the best coverage along with the best pricing possible

Johnny L.

22:49 16 Dec 20

Maggie Van B.

18:36 16 Dec 20

My fellow teacher highly recommended Monty. He helped me find reasonable insurance for my house and barn after State Farm dropped me after an ice damage claim.

Cindy P.

17:46 16 Dec 20

Always kind helpful when I’ve contacted them

Dustin J. W.

17:10 16 Dec 20

Great customer service. Highly recommended.

Hayley 'Cairns' P.

16:43 16 Dec 20

Great company to work with:)

Don W.

23:12 01 Oct 20

Monty is awesome to work with

Sara P.

20:52 18 Sep 20

Monty always responds quickly and does a great job!

Shay S.

19:52 18 Sep 20

Monty Homewood did a great job of matching our family up with the coverages needed. Everything was on time, accurate, and saved us money. Well done!

Jim T.

18:45 18 Sep 20

I’ve been with Monty Homewood insurance since about 2007 haven’t gone anywhere else, my Son recommended me to him and I’ve been there ever since .He’s a good man to deal with and I would recommend him to anyone to everyone! It’s just the right thing to do.

Gale G.

17:09 18 Sep 20

Susan M.

21:04 17 Apr 20

Monty has been my agent for many years, he does his best to find the best price for insurance for me. He has always been prompt to return my calls and help with any claims. I would recommend my agent.

Becca K.

16:57 17 Apr 20

Monty is always a pleasure to work with and is quick to help when I need it

Daniel A.

00:53 29 Mar 20

Homewood Insurance Agency found a lower rate in a fraction of the time. I have tried finding lower rates but failed each time.

William M.

17:56 26 Mar 20

Easy to work with, smooth transitioning

Jessie A.

17:04 26 Mar 20

I have been with Homewood Insurance Agency for many years. I have received the best rates.

Jonathan F.

16:58 26 Mar 20

Easy to do business with and willing to go the extra mile to address a unique situation we have insuring a VRBO property. Highly recommend Homewood Insurance Agency!

Jen M

15:59 26 Mar 20

Always helpful and got me a great rate

Brett S

13:44 31 Jan 20

Sue McCarthy H.

22:19 18 Dec 19

Monty has been so very helpful on any of my concerns & has responded quickly to take care of my insurance needs. Thank You.

Vania Garcia R.

04:19 16 Dec 19

Highly recommend Monty! Very good rates!

Bonnie F.

00:26 15 Dec 19

I have had good luck with Homewood Insurance. I switched to him on my daughter's recommendation. He is easy to work with. I am glad I switched.

Kelly O.

01:03 14 Dec 19

great, responsive agent!

James V.

16:34 13 Dec 19

I moved to Sun Prairie in July, 2018 and was looking for a good local independent agent who could find lower auto insurance rates. Even though I had been with American Family for decades, their rates were rising every year. I was happy with the options Monty provided, and have enjoyed the savings.

luke S.

16:20 13 Dec 19

Incredibly responsive and great service.

Steven M.

02:05 24 Nov 19

Jeri M.

15:33 20 Sep 19

Monty was very prompt and reassuring when a tree limb smashed the whole windshield just as I got in the car. I was freaked out as it pushed the rear view mirror inward about 10 inches from my head!

Carmela M.

02:11 18 Sep 19

Monty Homewood is always very responsive- often within the hour. You can't beat that for customer service!!

Greg A.

02:04 18 Sep 19

Monty was my agent for as long as I could remember (I think more that 15 years...). Always providing with best rates and always fought for my family's interest. Highly recommend him!

Монти -- мой агент на протяжении последних 15+ лет. Всегда находил наилучшие варианты для меня и боролся за интересы моей семьи.

John F.

14:38 06 Aug 19

I have worked with Monty for many years. He has always been both professional and friendly.

Brian L.

02:27 18 Jul 19

Mary L.

22:23 12 Jun 19

Always get a timely response back to any question I ask.

Michele W.

14:58 29 Apr 19

Chris has been our insurance agent for 20 years. She has always been professional and helpful. She even made the effort to call us after a tornado passed close to our home several years back to make sure we and our home were okay. We highly recommend her.

Dan M.

22:07 04 Feb 19

I’ve been working with Monty for about 20 years, and he answers any of my questions that may come up. He continues to check for better rates before I renew my policy. He is my auto and homeowners agent. I definitely recommend Monty for your insurance needs.

Dan M.

22:04 04 Feb 19

I’ve been working with Monty for about 20 years, and he will help whenever I have any questions. He continues to check for lowest rates every time I’m up for renewal.

Casey L.

19:01 21 Dec 18

I have had both my home and my automobiles all insured with the Homewood Insurance Agency for over 10 years now, and every time that I get calls from other insurance companies that try to beat Homewoods rates for comparable insurance they just can't do it.The service is also right on the money all of the time. Truly a FIRST CLASS operation with service and prices to match.

Michael R.

16:48 12 Nov 18

Monty is truly the best. I have been with him since 2000 and have always received first class service from him. He is always available to answer your questions and responds quickly. If you need him, he will be there for you! I have all my insurance through him and will not look anywhere else.Highly recommended.

Chuck M.

15:15 08 Oct 18

Susan Ann T.

02:49 29 Sep 18

Monty has been my agent for many years, he does his best to find the best price for insurance for me. He has always been prompt to return my calls and help with any claims. I would recommend my agent.

Sandy G.

00:15 26 Sep 18

Monty is real good about looking out for you and making sure you get a good company. He does al the work for you and is very personable

Michael K.

21:43 25 Sep 18

Been with Monty for years!

Julie R.

18:25 21 Sep 18

Monty has always responded quickly to any questions we have had. He is also looking to keep our rates very affordable. Thank you for all you do!

Shep Z.

22:25 02 Aug 18

Always responsive, and very fast. And always looks for best rates.

Cynthia J.

22:32 22 Jun 18

Linda A.

18:20 22 Jun 18

I have been one of Monty's clients for well over a decade. My husband and sons have policies with him too. He listens to our needs, and matches products accordingly. He is attentive and responsive to our questions and issues.

John L.

16:41 22 Jun 18

Best insurance guy ever i have had monty for 30 years i think

Jennifer M.

16:38 22 Jun 18

Friendly, fast service. Response time is great. Got a great rate on home/car insurance.

Leslie G.

16:53 14 May 18

Chris was helpful and found us a great rate with everything we needed. I love that she is able to run quotes with a few different companies to make sure we had the best rate and coverage possible. Polite and a pleasure to work with. I found Chris through numerous friends who had nothing but great things to say about her also. Happy to have found her.

Shirley G.

17:19 24 Apr 18

We are very happy with Monty. Always responds right away. We have told our friends and family.

Phyllis S.

09:05 09 Apr 18

Always friendly, very knowledgeable, and the best rates around! Thanks Homewood Ins Agency for all you do!

B G.

10:55 28 Mar 18

I have used Monty and Homewood insurance as my condo, home and car insurance provider for the last 13 yeas. He has always responded to me personally with any questions and in a timely manner. Finding me the most competitive rates and assisting personally with any claims, questions or payment changes. There isn't anything else I would like from him! So thankful he was referred to me so many years ago!

Mitch P.

23:16 27 Mar 18

We have had Monty as our insurance agent for more than a decade, and in that time, have had several claims (unfortunately), but the service and response from Monty has been outstanding. He understands our needs, finds the right insurance for us, and when needed, is prompt and effective in handling our claims. I highly recommend working with Monty for your insurance needs!

Jodi N.

23:03 27 Mar 18

jodi N.

23:03 27 Mar 18

Jenn G.

22:09 27 Mar 18

Never disappointed. If I have a question or concern Monte always responds very quickly. He is always willing to go the extra mile, it’s greatly appreciated!!!

Cheryl H.

20:33 27 Mar 18

I have been with Homewood Insurance for over 15 years and have referred Monty to friends and family. He responds in a timely, professional manner. Highly recommend this Agency!

steve I.

14:29 27 Mar 18

Nothing but praise for Monty and his service. Always on the ball returning calls or emails! Thanks Monty!

Alan A.

17:48 17 Jan 18

Great Service, so far! Great rate on Home & Auto! Monty responds in a timely fashion! Thanks.

Kevin B.

03:44 22 Dec 17

Monty Homewood is one of the best insurance agents I have ever had. He is very responsive and always listens to your needs. I live in Neenah now but will leave Monty. My daughter now has him for her condo, so he will stay in the family. Thank you Monty

Joel B.

20:47 21 Dec 17

Promptly handles any questions I have. Was able to find me lower rates for the same coverage I had with a different company.

Bonnie F.

23:13 26 Sep 17

Monty was recommended to me by my daughter Jody. He found me a policy similar to what I had at a cheaper cost. I have had no problems and plan to continue getting my insurance thru Monty.

Tim G.

01:11 29 Jun 17

Monty is the best agent we ever had. He listens to our needs and matches us up with what we want. He has done great for us. I highly recommend him.

Lawrence S.

16:45 27 Jun 17

Been with Monty for a long time. Very professional and responsive. Always works hard to get you the best price. Treats you as if you are his only client.

Tina B.

21:56 24 Apr 17

We have had our insurance with Chris for years. She always strives to get us the best rate and best coverage possible. She is informative, thoughtful and makes sure we have the coverage we need.

Janice W.

12:36 18 Mar 17

Monty is always very helpful, either with claims or adding/deleting cars. He got us the best policy that makes sense for our family.

Daniel H.

17:11 17 Mar 17

Monty is always quick to respond to messages and helpful over the phone. Good rates, quick quotes, and friendly service.

Theresa W.

13:02 17 Mar 17

My husband needed a Certificate of Insurance for his commercial business quickly. Monty turned the request around in a day and my husband's business was awarded the project. Monty also emails out newsletters which are very informative and have great tips. You can't go wrong with Monty!

Margaret M.

23:05 16 Mar 17

Monty has helped me for a couple years. No matter what the situation he is always there to answer my questions in a helpful manner. I will definitely keep Monty as my car insurance agent.

John L.

17:08 16 Mar 17

Joel F.

16:44 16 Mar 17

Monty has helped us through switching insurance companies, and a few claims. He is highly recommended!

Lisa P.

16:30 16 Mar 17

Called many places for car insurance quotes. Monty Homewood beat them all. Was with Geico for a few years but when (for no reason) they jacked up my rate by about a third I dumped them. They are still trying to "win" me back. It's worth the time to see if you can get a better rate.

Lud H.

15:06 16 Mar 17

We've been with Peter Walton for several years and are very pleased with their ability to provide prompt, courteous, and competitive service, not matter if Peter himself is available when we call. We've been with many other agencies in the past but do find his agency to be one of the very best we have ever had represent our interests.

Tim C.

02:49 27 Dec 16

Monty has helped us over 11 years with great coverage for home and auto.
He has always been there for us when we needed him most with prompt complete answers and direction. We have told several people about his agency as a family member did for us. Thanks Monty!

Audrey P.

17:37 06 Jul 16

Monty is a great agent. I have been with him for years and have recommended him to many of my friends.

Zach H.

20:52 06 Apr 16

Monty is always very fast to respond to my requests. I tell everyone I know to seek him out for their insurance needs.

JoEllen E.

10:56 10 Oct 15

Monty took a look at our current insurance and saved us a bundle by switching. I wonder how many more years we would have overpaid if not for him!

Mark A. S.

17:07 08 Sep 15

Dealing with Monty has always been a pleasure. He is very efficient and is always available for any of my insurance concerns.He is fantastic at always getting me the best rates for my needs. Highly recommended!

Carolina D.

20:56 24 Jun 15

Working with Monty is a great process; we worked with him and then moved out of Madison but, after working with other offices I decided to come back to Monty. Thanks for shopping around for us and get us the best deal out there.
Work with someone you can trust - that would be Monty Homewood. Great job!

Boguslaw M.

04:00 13 Dec 14

The best insurance agency there is! We all heard that 15 minutes could save you... or 7.5 minutes could save you... But the TRUTH is you will save a lot more with Homewood Insurance Agency.

Katie B.

19:56 22 Sep 14

I love working with Monty. Every time we have a question, he answers it quickly and is always very helpful!! He has great rates and is super easy to work with.

Ryan M.

23:36 07 Jul 14

Phyllis S.

10:09 14 Jun 14

I recommend this agent to everyone that is looking for insurance. He has some of the best rates around and always friendly!

Andrew J K.

03:21 12 Jul 13